Online Now 865

Unconquered

The place to talk about the Florida State Seminoles

On this Board 560
Record: 3837 (2/3/2013)

Online now 821
Record: 5859 (2/14/2012)

Boards ▾

Unconquered

The place to talk about the Florida State Seminoles

Off The Reservation

The place to discuss general topics outside of Florida State

Reply

title 9 and FSU men's

  • With news of our beach volleyball team I was thinking about its relevance to title 9. I was under the impression that there had to be an equal number of men’s and women’s sports. At my count we have 8 men’s and now have 10 women’s. Does this not mean that we can have more men’s sports? I would really love for us to finally bring on a men’s soccer team and make the la ’cross team official.

    cembros

  • cembros said...

    With news of our beach volleyball team I was thinking about its relevance to title 9. I was under the impression that there had to be an equal number of men’s and women’s sports. At my count we have 8 men’s and now have 10 women’s. Does this not mean that we can have more men’s sports? I would really love for us to finally bring on a men’s soccer team and make the la ’cross team official.

    No there needs to be parity with the total amount of scholarships available. Because football offers 85 there are more women's sports needed.

    signature image signature image signature image

    fsufool

  • I see, wasn't aware of that. I wonder what the count for each is.

    cembros

  • I really hope that this could potentially open the door for FSU to field a varsity Men's Soccer Team. Being a fan of the "beautiful game," I would love to see this become a reality.

    The ACC is loaded with quality teams and it baffles me that both schools in Florida don't have a team. Florida is a hotbed for soccer talent and I believe it's a sport FSU could instantly be competitive and challenge for titles.

    TN NoleFan 8254651

  • The issue here is Football. with 85 scholarships it really skews the numbers.

    signature image signature image signature image

    ZZ1059

  • TN NoleFan '82 said...

    I really hope that this could potentially open the door for FSU to field a varsity Men's Soccer Team. Being a fan of the "beautiful game," I would love to see this become a reality.

    The ACC is loaded with quality teams and it baffles me that both schools in Florida don't have a team. Florida is a hotbed for soccer talent and I believe it's a sport FSU could instantly be competitive and challenge for titles.

    Agreed. Unfortunately our short sighted athletic department wants to field a lacrosse team before soccer, strictly because the coach has some money to back it. UCF and USF have soccer teams, along with UNF, Stetson, JU, UWF, FAU, FIU, Rollins, and some small schools. UCF, USF, and JU typically field quality teams. USF finished the season 6th and makes the tourney most years.

    FSU could build a top 10-15 team in a matter of a few years and there will be exponentially more fan support than lacrosse will ever get. One of the problems with FSU being in Tallahassee is that a lot of FSU employees are out of touch with the rest of Florida and are more South Georgia/Bama than Florida.

    JeffSpicNolie

  • JeffSpicNolie said...

    Agreed. Unfortunately our short sighted athletic department wants to field a lacrosse team before soccer, strictly because the coach has some money to back it. UCF and USF have soccer teams, along with UNF, Stetson, JU, UWF, FAU, FIU, Rollins, and some small schools. UCF, USF, and JU typically field quality teams. USF finished the season 6th and makes the tourney most years.

    FSU could build a top 10-15 team in a matter of a few years and there will be exponentially more fan support than lacrosse will ever get. One of the problems with FSU being in Tallahassee is that a lot of FSU employees are out of touch with the rest of Florida and are more South Georgia/Bama than Florida.

    Jeff I believe you and I have had this conversation before on WC

    signature image signature image signature image

    ZZ1059

  • Title IX isn't fully understood by most. It's based on a 3 pronged approach where you need to meet just one of the criteria listed below. The number of football scholarships don't necessarily play a part in it.

    Prong one - Providing athletic participation opportunities that are substantially proportionate to the student enrollment. This part of the test is satisfied when participation opportunities for men and women are "substantially proportionate" to their respective undergraduate enrollment.

    Prong two - Demonstrate a continual expansion of athletic opportunities for the underrepresented sex. This part of the test is satisfied when an institution has a history and continuing practice of program expansion that is responsive to the developing interests and abilities of the underrepresented sex (typically female).

    Prong three - Full and effective accommodation of the interest and ability of underrepresented sex. This part of the test is satisfied when an institution is meeting the interests and abilities of its female students even where there are disproportionately fewer females than males participating in sports.

    Matt Lauer

  • ZZ1059 said...

    Jeff I believe you and I have had this conversation before on WC

    Haha. Yea I've beaten this to a dead horse before. Really grinds my gears.

    I talked to one of the athletic department execs about it, but didn't have time to have prolonged discussions on it.

    JeffSpicNolie

  • JeffSpicNolie said...

    Haha. Yea I've beaten this to a dead horse before. Really grinds my gears.

    I talked to one of the athletic department execs about it, but didn't have time to have prolonged discussions on it.

    You are correct though. Most of the ACC recruits Florida insanely. I went to NC State for soccer, hated the coach and came back to FSU. Knew a lot of people that went to Maryland, came to State with me, and so on.

    With the resources that we have in this state alone we could be a contender for a top 12 program every year.

    signature image signature image signature image

    ZZ1059

  • Matt Lauer said...

    Title IX isn't fully understood by most. It's based on a 3 pronged approach where you need to meet just one of the criteria listed below. The number of football scholarships don't necessarily play a part in it.

    Prong one - Providing athletic participation opportunities that are substantially proportionate to the student enrollment. This part of the test is satisfied when participation opportunities for men and women are "substantially proportionate" to their respective undergraduate enrollment.

    Prong two - Demonstrate a continual expansion of athletic opportunities for the underrepresented sex. This part of the test is satisfied when an institution has a history and continuing practice of program expansion that is responsive to the developing interests and abilities of the underrepresented sex (typically female).

    Prong three - Full and effective accommodation of the interest and ability of underrepresented sex. This part of the test is satisfied when an institution is meeting the interests and abilities of its female students even where there are disproportionately fewer females than males participating in sports.

    That’s interesting. So there are no quantitative requirements? I always thought there had to be an equal number of some sort, dollars or sports.

    This post was edited by cembros on 3/9/2012 at 12:17 PM

    cembros

  • JeffSpicNolie said...

    FSU could build a top 10-15 team in a matter of a few years and there will be exponentially more fan support than lacrosse will ever get. One of the problems with FSU being in Tallahassee is that a lot of FSU employees are out of touch with the rest of Florida and are more South Georgia/Bama than Florida.

    Maybe it would be top 10-15 in a few years. But I doubt it'd be as simple as that. There are some very good, established programs that we wouldn't just crack into. And exponentially more fan support than lacrosse? Just a wee bit of an hyperbole there.

    Whichever sport is added next, if we add another, will be determined by the finances. If there is more money backing a potential lacrosse program than soccer, we'd be stupid to invest in soccer. Period. That would also seem to indicate there isn't more support for soccer than lacrosse, but this is just a hypothetical.

    And I'm pretty sure the number of scholarships for the men and women don't have to be equal. Thought they had to be proportional to the percentage of male and female students on campus. I believe they include walk-ons in these figures and even include some men in the women's totals if, for example, it's some guys acting as a practice squad for the women's volleyball or basketball team to go up against. (EDIT: I see Matt Lauer touched upon this already and provided more insight.)

    This post was edited by tricknole on 3/9/2012 at 12:23 PM

    tricknole

  • Title IX is horrible. If the sport can't make money, cut it. Simple as that.

    RaidingNole

  • ZZ1059 said...

    You are correct though. Most of the ACC recruits Florida insanely. I went to NC State for soccer, hated the coach and came back to FSU. Knew a lot of people that went to Maryland, came to State with me, and so on.

    With the resources that we have in this state alone we could be a contender for a top 12 program every year.

    Yea there is a ton of talent in the state, heck even at FSU. I ended up playing JUCO in Georgia (goofed on grades in high school). Was conference freshmen of the year and was getting recruited by some top 25 D1 teams, but transferred to FSU to hang with my friends and now ex-GF. Had no interest in playing on the club team here, but did play around campus a lot, and there were a lot of kids who had talent to play college ball. Back then (2000) there were little to no pro prospects, so you had a lot of kids who came from money or had Bright Futures that preferred to go to FSU/UF over playing soccer at JU, Stetson, UCF, etc.

    With the growth of MLS and the fact that European teams are scouting here much more, busting your ass in college soccer is a lot more viable than it used to be. Getting to play in the ACC against all the powers would instantly make FSU the #1 team in the state. Plus we already have great facilities from the women's team.

    One of these days I'll do some research to show the athletic department.

    JeffSpicNolie

  • cembros said...

    That’s interesting. So there are no quantitative requirements? I always thought there had to be an equal number of some sort, dollars or sports.

    that's what most think because title IX isn't thoroughly explained. I went to Alabama for my Masters in Sports Management and we had many a class discussion and had to write papers on the subject. It's been a while so I don't remember everything, but there is no hard line to follow. Now the "proprtion issue" comes in to play with the 85 ships for football because it leads to the ladies being "underrepresented" but there is no specific guideline to follow.

    FSU adding Sand Volleyball fits in to Prong Two. They are doing something to advance womens sports which in theory means that they could add mens sports as well as long as they are doing something for the ladies.

    The big issue is that none of these produce revenue. That's why it's hard to add additional sports because it puts more of a strain on the athletic department as a whole.

    Matt Lauer

  • RaidingNole said...

    Title IX is horrible. If the sport can't make money, cut it. Simple as that.

    lol

    There would only be two college sports and most schools would only have one or none.

    tricknole

  • tricknole said...

    Maybe it would be top 10-15 in a few years. But I doubt it'd be as simple as that. There are some very good, established programs that we wouldn't just crack into. And exponentially more fan support than lacrosse? Just a wee bit of an hyperbole there.

    Whichever sport is added next, if we add another, will be determined by the finances. If there is more money backing a potential lacrosse program than soccer, we'd be stupid to invest in soccer. Period. That would also seem to indicate there isn't more support for soccer than lacrosse, but this is just a hypothetical.

    And I'm pretty sure the number of scholarships for the men and women don't have to be equal. Thought they had to be proportional to the percentage of male and female students on campus. I believe they include walk-ons in these figures and even include some men in the women's totals if, for example, it's some guys acting as a practice squad for the women's volleyball or basketball team to go up against. (EDIT: I see Matt Lauer touched upon this already and provided more insight.)

    Start a mens soccer team. Top 10-15 team in a years. It is as simple as that. The ACC is the best conference for men's soccer. We have great facilities. We have a great brand name. We would be the highest profile soccer team in one of the most talented states in the country.

    No hyperbole. Soccer is way more popular than lacrosse in Florida. I know lacrosse people say otherwise, but its not comparable. Even in the most popular lacrosse states in the country (Maryland/Virginia) their soccer teams still outdraw lacrosse. I don't have the data, but did on a WC thread a few years ago. Pro soccer has gotten much more popular in recent years in the states. Just go to a sports bar in a major city and see how many people watch EPL games on Saturday/Sunday mornings.

    Of course it will be determined by finances. Money makes the world go round. What you must know be aware of, is the fact that the only reason lacrosse is ahead of soccer on the drawing board at FSU, is because the coach of the club team is wealthy and has backed the team. Not because there will be more support across our fan base. Our athletic department has never attempted to see how much financial support there would be for soccer. I know someone that I'm fairly confident would give a 6 figure donation for FSU soccer, and I'm sure there are countless others. FSU mens soccer will make WAY more money off jersey sales. I have never and will never buy a football or basketball jersey, but I would buy 2 men's soccer jersey's the day they came out. Thousands of others would too. Do you know how awesome an FSU Nike mens's soccer would look? Every f'n hipster in the state would buy one. Soccer would get more donations from across the state, and would get higher attendance than lacrosse.

    Basically our athletic department would be starting lacrosse solely because the coach of the club team wants it. Not because it is in the best long term interest of the athletic department.

    JeffSpicNolie

  • JeffSpicNolie said...

    Start a mens soccer team. Top 10-15 team in a years. It is as simple as that.

    Basically our athletic department would be starting lacrosse solely because the coach of the club team wants it. Not because it is in the best long term interest of the athletic department.

    All opinion.

    tricknole

  • tricknole said...

    All opinion.

    Based on knowing more than you about the matter.

    JeffSpicNolie

  • I played Lacrosse at FSU and I totally agree that Soccer is a way bigger sport and deserves to be the next sport added at FSU. Our Women's team draws rather large crowds. I can only imagine what the men would draw. We cal also add in that Soccer is the #1 sports played by youth in America.

    Truth about coach harkins. That guy paid for the turf practice field himself.

    Matt Lauer

  • Matt Lauer said...

    I played Lacrosse at FSU and I totally agree that Soccer is a way bigger sport and deserves to be the next sport added at FSU. Our Women's team draws rather large crowds. I can only imagine what the men would draw. We cal also add in that Soccer is the #1 sports played by youth in America.

    Truth about coach harkins. That guy paid for the turf practice field himself.

    Thanks Matt. I wasn't trying to knock lacrosse. Its a cool sport and has grown quite a bit. It's just that it can never get as big as soccer (simply because of how big the sport is globally). The amount of money being thrown around in Europe is disgusting. Right now a lot of the Middle East oil money is flowing into soccer teams. For some reason the Sheiks all want their own teams. A lot of the clubs there are not only scouting here more, but investing in the development of the game. As soccer becomes more affordable/accessible for low income African Americans, you will start to see more of our "elite" athletes playing the game as well.

    Yea its pretty well known that Coach Harkins has been great to FSU and that he is the reason we are considering adding an official lacrosse team. An athletic department administrator has told me so. So not sure how that is an "opinion"

    JeffSpicNolie

  • I played in 99-00 so I didn't have the luxury to play under Harkins. Very interesting about adding a mens lacrosse program. Selfishly I would love that, but I really get in to World Cup and Olympic soccer so I'm sure I would quickly fall in love if FSU had a men's team.

    Matt Lauer

  • I should also add that I am not advocating for starting a men's soccer team. Simply that if another team is added, it should be soccer over lacrosse.

    Our athletic department and the Boosters need to focus on the IPF, College Town, endowing scholarships, Doak renovations, and improving the Tucker Center before anything else.

    JeffSpicNolie

  • JeffSpicNolie said...

    I should also add that I am not advocating for starting a men's soccer team. Simply that if another team is added, it should be soccer over lacrosse.

    If lacrosse has more financial backing it should be that.

    tricknole

  • tricknole said...

    If lacrosse has more financial backing it should be that.

    One person with money does not equal more financial backing.
    That would be a very short sighted decision.
    Soccer should be the next sport because of its popularity in Florida and would serve the student population better. It's that simple.

    Interesting info about Title 9. Always thought it was the 85 football scholarships that were weighing heavily into the decision.

    signature image signature image signature image

    fsufool