Unconquered

I agree with you. College football is very much a "what have you done for me lately" culture, and FSU hasn't done very much.

Unfortunately this is a discussion where no FSU fan can claim to be objective, just like no SCAR fan (or SEC homer could either).

Tradition, past success, recruiting, etc all point to FSU.

Conference superiority, program buzz, recent success, etc are in favor of Carolina.

10 years ago, there would've been no contest, and 10 years from now it may be no contest again.

But right now, leaving a program like South Carolina for FSU isn't the no brained some fans think it is. Especially since he is already there.